Book Review: We Who Will Die, Stacia Stark

Life in the perilous Thorn district is a constant battle for Arvelle and her younger brothers. And the vampire standing on her doorstep is about to turn their world upside down.

Faced with an unthinkable choice, Arvelle makes a magically binding vow to do the impossible: kill the emperor, an ancient vampire created by the god Umbros. But first, she must enter the Sundering—an arena where only the fastest, strongest, and deadliest survive long enough to be selected for the emperor’s elite guard.

She quickly draws the ire of the Primus, the powerful figure charged with protecting the emperor. But the vampire under the armor is the last person Arvelle expects to encounter in the emperor’s court.

With her brothers’ lives in the balance, Arvelle has no choice but to ally with the man who once shattered her heart… and with the emperor’s sadistic son, Rorrik—two vampires whose motives are impossible to pin down. Rorrik holds the key to understanding the powers Arvelle is developing—abilities that would put a price on her head if discovered by the emperor.

To survive the arena and complete her mission, Arvelle must get to the bottom of a conspiracy that will change everything she thought she knew about herself—and the two vampires who are deeply entwined with her destiny…

Published by: Avon
Publication Date: December 30, 2025

Shop The Book: We Who Will Die
Shop My Stack: 2026 Books Read

I picked this up as my Book of the Month pick because I was seeing it everywhere, especially on Bookstagram, and I needed to know what all the hype was about.

Fantasy, dystopian elements, a historical setting, and vampires? That combination was already enough to pull me in.

Reading Experience

I knew within the first couple of pages that I had made the right choice.

I had just finished The Hunger Games series, and this book gave me that same kind of intensity, but in a completely different setting. There are clear nods to gladiator-style games in ancient Rome, which adds a really strong historical influence, but the addition of magic, vampires, and fantasy elements gives it this almost timeless or even dystopian feel.

The pacing worked really well for me. I was pulled in immediately, and it held my attention the entire time. The emotional depth of the characters made it easy to stay invested, and I found myself fully immersed in their struggles and motivations.

Story Structure

The story is told from Arvelle’s point of view, but even within that single perspective, we get a deep understanding of the people around her.

There are also moments where she relives past trauma through flashbacks, particularly surrounding the loss of her best friend in the arena. These moments were difficult to read at times, but they added so much depth to her character and her emotional journey.

Her struggle with guilt and grief becomes a central part of the story, and watching her begin to confront and process those feelings was one of the most powerful aspects of the book.

Characters

I loved Arvelle as a main character. She’s driven, loyal, and shaped by everything she’s been through, especially her need to protect her younger brothers.

Her relationship with her brothers was one of my favorite parts of the story. You can feel how much they rely on each other and how strong that bond is, even in incredibly difficult circumstances.

And then there’s Tiernan.

I have read a lot of books, and I have never really been someone who gets attached to the whole “book boyfriend” idea… until now. Tiernan completely changed that for me. The history between him and Arvelle, the tension, the chemistry, and everything left unsaid made their dynamic one of the most compelling parts of the story.

The other competitors in the arena also stood out. Each of them felt like they had their own story, their own reasons for being there, and their own struggles, which made it very easy to get emotionally attached.

I also really appreciated the depth given to the antagonists. You get a sense of what shaped them and what they’ve endured, which adds another layer to the story.

Tone

This story carries a strong sense of desperation from the very beginning.

Arvelle is fighting for her family, for survival, and for a future that feels just out of reach. There’s a constant undercurrent of grief and loss, especially tied to her past experiences in the arena and the guilt she carries with her.

At the same time, there are powerful themes of resilience, loyalty, and learning how to move forward after loss.

Layered into that is a mix of romance, tension, distrust, and rekindled connections that add even more emotional weight to the story.

Final Thoughts

This was one of those books that pulled me in immediately and didn’t let go.

The emotional depth, the relationships, the setting, and the high-stakes tension all worked together to create a story that I was completely invested in from beginning to end.

And now I’m left waiting… because I absolutely do not want to wait for the next book, but I’m going to have to.

👉 Grab this month’s BOTM pick here: Join for only $5

Stacia Stark is a New York Times, USA Today, Sunday Times, and Amazon bestselling author of fantasy romance. Her books have been translated into over 16 languages, and her Kingdom of Lies series was nominated twice for Goodreads Choice Awards.

Stacia loves writing romantasy filled with found families, female friendship, self-reliant heroines, and brooding, grumpy heroes. When she’s not writing or exploring the world, she can usually be found sprawled on her sofa, lost in the pages of a good book.

Leave a comment

I’m Ashley

Welcome to my Blog! Here, you’ll find my honest reviews of books that touched my soul, books that were great for a weekend in, or maybe some books that weren’t my cup of tea. I’ll also share my favorite products and how they help make our home cozy and efficient. I love to connect so make yourselves friendly in the comments!

Follow me on YouTube!

Follow me on Insta!